1.
Two differentiable functions \(u\) and \(v\) are graphed below near \(x=1\) . Note: These graphs are symmetric about a horizontal line defined where they intersect.-
Without formulas, determine the sign (positive, negative, or zero) of \((uv)'(1)\) . Explain using the product rule and the picture.
-
Determine the sign of \(\left(\dfrac{u}{v}\right)'(1)\) . Explain using the quotient rule and the picture.
Answer.
-
At \(x=1\) , the graph shows: \(u(1) > 0, u'(1) > 0,\) \(v(1) > 0,{\text{ and }}v'(1) = - u'(1) < 0.\) Note that\begin{equation*} (uv)'(1) = u'(1)v(1)+u(1)v'(1). \end{equation*}The first term is positive (positive slope times positive value). The second term is negative (positive times negative). Since, \(v'(1)=-u'(1)\) and \(0 < u(1) < v(1)\) , the first (positive) term dominates.
-
Note that\begin{equation*} \displaystyle \left( \frac{u}{v}\right)'(1) = \frac{u'(1)v(1)-u(1)v'(1)}{v(1)^{2}}. \end{equation*}The denominator is positive. In the numerator, \(u'(1)v(1) > 0\) and \(-u(1)v'(1)\) is also positive since \(v'(1)<0\) . Adding these is positive. Hence the fraction is also positive.



